HMS Echo remembers Arctic convoy heroes during search for sunken WW2 cruiser

Topic: Fighting armsSurface Fleet Storyline: HMS Echo

Royal Navy survey ship HMS Echo returned to waters where sailors once faced Nazi bombers and U-boats to pay tribute to the first Arctic convoy 80 years ago.

The Devonport-based ship paused in the middle of the Barents Sea to remember the men of Operation Dervish – and the thousands who followed them, delivering vital aid to the Soviet Union between 1941 and 1945.

Echo has been conducting survey work in the High North, including searching for the wreck of one sunken WW2 cruiser and updating existing information about another, HMS Edinburgh, over whose wreck Echo’s crew held a service of remembrance.

As Echo’s Commanding Officer Commander Adam Coles cast a wreath into the Barents Sea, the Russian cruiser Marshal Ustinov – which was sailing nearby – signalled the Royal Navy vessel in admiration of the men of 1941-45.

The crew of the Ustinov praised a generation which “served with great honour, bravery and determination…in the face of Fascist invaders.

“To all those who sacrificed themselves in the fight against our common enemy, the memory of them and our warriors will forever live in our hearts.

“Congratulations on the 80th anniversary of the Arctic convoys to all Royal Navy servicemen, may they always be held high above us all.”

Hydrographic specialist Able Seaman Cameron Siddall said: “It has been fascinating learning about the history of the Arctic Convoys, particularly as HMS Echo operated in the very same waters that were traversed by the brave merchantmen and warships 80 years ago.”

Petty Officer Calvin Spencer’s great uncle was an 18-year-old sailor aboard destroyer HMS Matchless which rescued six sailors from the German battlecruiser Scharnhorst on Boxing Day in 1943.

“My grandad says Frank would never speak about anything he witnessed on the Arctic Convoys,” he said. “Seeing the conditions up here myself, during the summer months, without even being under the threat of enemy attack, I can only imagine the horror the brave sailors from both sides went through.”

Even in late summer, temperatures are barely into double figures at 72 degrees North, while anyone ending up in the water will lose feeling in their fingers and toes inside five minutes, be unconscious inside 30, and probably dead within an hour.

Echo used her sensors to conduct the first survey of the wreck of HMS Edinburgh in 40 years. The cruiser was scuttled in May 1942 after a German submarine blew apart her stern as she carried gold back to Britain.

Weather conditions and the depth of the wreck – 245 metres down – meant that although the wreck was clearly identifiable, finer details could not.

Sailing over the wreck was especially poignant for Echo. Her wartime forebear, an E-class destroyer, had accompanied Edinburgh on an earlier convoy. As she escorted a merchant ship into Murmansk, she was attacked by a couple of German bombers and two men were swept off the forecastle as the ship took evasive action.

The survey vessel also spent 32 hours looking for cruiser HMS Trinidad, also lost in May 1942.

Trinidad is thought to lie 440 metres down, but could be anywhere in nearly 400 square kilometres of sea bed – and she’s only 170 metres long.

Despite an extensive search using records provided by the Royal Navy’s official historians and the UK Hydrographic Office definite evidence of the wreck could not be found.

“The survey work has been really rewarding, from collecting the data to producing a finished product. The search for HMS Trinidad was especially exciting,” said Leading Seaman ‘Bill’ Bailey, one of Echo’s hydrographic specialists.

Commander Coles added: “While the search for Trinidad was ultimately inconclusive, it was still a good chance to utilise Echo’s survey equipment.

“The wreck investigation on HMS Edinburgh proved a chance to gain valuable data for the UKHO, as well as to remember an important part of the Royal Navy’s heritage, including commemorating the many people who lost their lives during the Arctic Convoys.”

In all, 16 Royal Navy warships were lost and 1,944 Senior Service personnel were killed, while 85 of the 1,400 merchant ships which took part in the Arctic runs were sunk, killing 800 merchant sailors.

They delivered four million tonnes of supplies to the Soviet war effort – about one quarter of the total aid they provided to the USSR between 1941 and 1945.

The 7,000 aircraft and 5,000 tanks, plus trucks, cars, fuel, medicines, metals and other raw materials helped the Soviets to defeat the Germans on the Eastern Front.

The wreck investigation on HMS Edinburgh proved a chance to gain valuable data for the UKHO, as well as to remember an important part of the Royal Navy’s heritage, including commemorating the many people who lost their lives during the Arctic Convoys.

HMS Echo’s Commanding Officer Commander Adam Coles